// N-processor mutual exclusion [Rab82] // gxn/dxp 03/12/08 // to remove the need for fairness constraints for this model it is sufficent // to remove the self loops from the model // the step corresponding to a process making a draw has been split into two steps // to allow us to identify states where a process will draw without knowing the value // randomly drawn // to correctly model the protocol and prevent erroneous behaviour, the two steps are atomic // (i.e. no other process can move one the first step has been made) // as for example otherwise an adversary can prevent the process from actually drawing // in the current round by not scheduling it after it has performed the first step mdp // size of shared counter const int K = 6; // 4+ceil(log_2 N) // global variables (all modules can read and write) global c : [0..1]; // 0/1 critical section free/taken global b : [0..K]; // current highest draw global r : [1..2]; // current round // formula for process 1 drawing formula draw = p1=1 & (b<b1 | r!=r1); // formula to keep drawing phase atomic // (a process can only move if no other process is in the middle of drawing) formula go = (draw2=0&draw3=0); module process1 p1 : [0..2]; // local state // 0 remainder // 1 trying // 2 critical section b1 : [0..K]; // current draw: bi r1 : [0..2]; // current round: ri draw1 : [0..1]; // performed first step of drawing phase // remain in remainder // [] go & p1=0 -> (p1'=0); // enter trying [] go & p1=0 -> (p1'=1); // make a draw [] go & draw & draw1=0 -> (draw1'=1); [] draw1=1 -> 0.5 : (b1'=1) & (r1'=r) & (b'=max(b,1)) & (draw1'=0) + 0.25 : (b1'=2) & (r1'=r) & (b'=max(b,2)) & (draw1'=0) + 0.125 : (b1'=3) & (r1'=r) & (b'=max(b,3)) & (draw1'=0) + 0.0625 : (b1'=4) & (r1'=r) & (b'=max(b,4)) & (draw1'=0) + 0.03125 : (b1'=5) & (r1'=r) & (b'=max(b,5)) & (draw1'=0) + 0.03125 : (b1'=6) & (r1'=r) & (b'=max(b,6)) & (draw1'=0); // enter critical section and randomly set r to 1 or 2 [] go & p1=1 & b=b1 & r=r1 & c=0 -> 0.5 : (r'=1) & (c'=1) & (b'=0) & (b1'=0) & (r1'=0) & (p1'=2) + 0.5 : (r'=2) & (c'=1) & (b'=0) & (b1'=0) & (r1'=0) & (p1'=2); // loop when trying and cannot make a draw or enter critical section // [] go & p1=1 & r1=r & b1<=b & ((c=0 & b1!=b) | c=1) -> (p1'=p1); // leave crictical section [] go & p1=2 -> (p1'=0) & (c'=0); // stay in critical section // [] go & p1=2 -> (p1'=2); endmodule // construct further modules through renaming module process2 = process1 [p1=p2, b1=b2, r1=r2, draw1=draw2, draw2=draw1 ] endmodule module process3 = process1 [p1=p3, b1=b3, r1=r3, draw1=draw3, draw3=draw1 ] endmodule // formulas/labels for use in properties: // number of processes in critical section formula num_procs_in_crit = (p1=2?1:0)+(p2=2?1:0)+(p3=2?1:0); // one of the processes is trying label "one_trying" = p1=1|p2=1|p3=1; // one of the processes is in the critical section label "one_critical" = p1=2|p2=2|p3=2; // maximum current draw of the processes formula maxb = max(b1,b2,b3);